This Week In College Viability (TWICV) for December 16, 2024

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (00:01.278)
It is this week in college viability news and commentary for December 16, 2024. everybody, Gary Stocker back behind the cute blue Yeti microphone. And I have a big announcement to start off today's show. After reading and listening and watching traditional higher education media, I have realized somewhat belatedly that that

is not me. I don't really do cookbook stories on how to fix higher education on the margins. I don't engage in trite college stories about awesome or excited events or personalities. It's time. Here's the announcement. It's time for me to step forward and share that I am your self-appointed, yes that's right, your self-appointed higher education alternative media source.

Giggle, if you will. Roll your eyes, if you must. My operating premise, right or wrong, has been that higher education is in the midst of an economic model adjustment that will inevitably result in consolidation in the form of continuing college closures and increased merger activity. I try to be polite. I hope that comes across. Some have called me somewhat bombastic. I can live with that.

I do, though, offer sarcasm alerts. And I do. I have an interest in engaging in collegial discussions with those who have other thoughts and already plans in the making to engage to bring more folks onto the show, both this podcast and the College Financial Health Show with Matt Hendricks that we do every Tuesday in 2025. And I've also had many say, Gary, keep doing what you're doing. Many have said that. And to those, I thank you.

And this podcast and the other media that I do will continue to lovingly poke the current higher education bear in a never-ending attempt to do my small part to move the industry past its historical model and toward one that recognizes the higher education industry. It needs fewer colleges. I've said it before and I will continue to say it again.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (02:27.246)
in the future. And to layoffs and cutbacks, we start the show as we always do. Drexel University lays off 60 staffers due to enrollment drop and flawed FAFSA rollout is their excuse. And certainly the FAFSA rollout had an impact on Drexel and many other colleges. This story came from James Samuel on December 11th from the College Fix. At Drexel interim, President Dennis O'Brien attributed, get this, increased investments

in both financial aid to promote access and affordability and in student supports to ensure their success and well-being and rising costs associated with doing business as the main drivers of the university's budget imbalance. You'll hear that quote again in the college dribble section of today's podcast. Enrollment has consistently fallen at Drexel University.

since 2015. At what point did someone at Drexel or elsewhere even, besides us, besides me, stand up and say, hey, Houston or Drexel, we have a problem. In a recent message to the campus, interim president O'Brien said Drexel has created an academic transformation plan. Stop the process that involves cutting 150 million in expenses. That's a lot of money. By 2027.

to achieve sustainable positive operating margins. Nothing wrong with that at all. But again, why? Why? Why the weight?

At Drexel, many places, not, this financial challenge is not an overnight development. And it's a similar story across countless colleges in this country. There was a Mark Perry, I presume a doctor, Mark Perry, whose professor emeritus of economics at the University of Michigan, Flint, said in an email to the FIX, and that's who's reporting this story, that he does not believe, at Drexel, apparently, he does not believe overspending is the main issue.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (04:36.258)
Dr. Perry goes on to say the decline in enrollment at Drexel is consistent with the national decline in enrollment since 2010. Welcome to the show Dr. Perry via text, content. Dr. Perry, do respect. If you would actually look at the data, you would see the Drexel total expenses as their enrollment plummeted total Drexel expenses.

increased about $37 million. From 2015 to 2022, there was an expense issue. It's not just enrollment issues. They're connected for sure. And just as a sidebar, Matt Hendricks and I reviewed Drexel's Financial Health and Viability on the August 13th episode of the College Financial Health Show. I'll put a link in the show notes. So those of you that want to listen to that can go right to the YouTube video on that.

Moving on, Portland State to lay off 17 faculty members. The union says more layoffs could be coming. Just trying to keep everybody up to speed on layoffs. This is a public college, of course, in Oregon. And in San Francisco, entertainment value. San Francisco State faculty mourn upcoming layoffs in a New Orleans-style funeral march. story is from Allison Alexi, the San Francisco Examiner on December 11th. Yes.

They had fake caskets and many of the New Orleans accoutrements associated with a funeral at San Francisco State University. Positive points, positive points for creativity, negative endpoints for actually doing anything, negative points for impact. And onto something that a lot of you liked after I introduced this just last week on the podcast. It's time for the college drivel section.

where we take information from colleges that just seems so goofy, so silly, so fluffy, as to be worth giggling about. I'll start with one that says, our commitment, and again, for these college drivel quotes, now I don't attribute them, I may change that, but for now I'm not going to. Our commitment to providing high quality learning experiences to the most diverse student body in the region at an affordable cost.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (07:00.098)
continues to be what sets this university apart," said a senior leader. And like I shared before from the good folks at Drexel, increased investments both in financial aid to promote access, these are discounts, no extra dollars transferred, increased investments both in financial aid to promote access and affordability and in student supports to ensure 50 % graduation rates. I have to check what Drexel is.

and to ensure their success and well-being and rising costs associated with doing business as the main drivers of the university's budget imbalance. I don't even know what that means. That's a line, that's three lines going in all sorts of directions. And then finally, from an English department person in a private Midwest college.

It goes on to say that many of the programs affected in their cutbacks at this college are in the humanities and languages, making those disciplines less available to rural students than they are to urban and suburban ones. This is the part that gets me. These subjects, I guess humanities and languages, these subjects do much of the work helping students dream beyond their realities.

said this English department chair at a private Midwestern college. Great. Now, I don't want to have all the fun here. So, to listeners, send me your college drivel quotes. Send them to me, gary at college viability. That's one word, gary at college viability.com. Let me know if you want attribution. Happy to offer it. If not, I will certainly keep that confidential as well. And remember, I won't use a person's name.

or college or business name in the college drivel quote. Although like I said at the top, I'm pondering whether to change my mind on that. Page two, Intel. You might remember them as the company who made chips in the early days of computers, especially home computers, personal computers. And they have fallen behind the times in the story. I'll include the link was from CNN, Claire Duffy at CNN earlier this month on December 4th. And the essence of the story was Intel was dominant

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (09:20.642)
but failed to keep up with technology and business trends. Where have we heard that before? If a name like Intel, a prominent dominant name like Intel struggles to survive in this era, what does that mean for colleges that refuse to aggressively or even just adapt to new technologies and business processes? That's a rhetorical question for you to ask.

and answer. Higher Ed's governance problem is the headline. This is from a guest essay that Dr. Brian Rosenberg did in the Chronicle on December 12th. And if you don't recall, Dr. Rosenberg wrote the book about this time last year entitled Whatever It Is, I'm Against It. He was a long-term president at Macalester College, I think, Macalester College in Minnesota. Again, higher Ed's governance problem. Boards are bloated.

and ineffectual, so says Dr. Rosenberg. Here's some content I'm going to paraphrase from Dr. Rosenberg's guest essay. According to the Association of Governing Boards of Universities and Colleges, the average size of a private, non-profit college or university board is 28. He makes note that that is larger than a major league baseball roster. Nice analogy, I like that.

By way of comparison, Brian Rosenberg continues to write, the average size of the board of directors of a publicly traded company, the IBM, Seattle, those kind of places, is nine. And if that, he goes on to write, if that seems too corporate, consider the average size of the board of a nonprofit healthcare institution is 13. 13 in healthcare, nonprofit healthcare, private nonprofit healthcare institutions.

And average size for nonprofit institutions more broadly is 17. And Dr. Rosenberg suggests that's probably elevated by the inclusion of so many large nonprofit private university boards. And most, again from Dr. Brian Rosenberg, most governance experts view these numbers to be on the high end of the optimal range, really high end. A study done by Bain Capital a while back, I don't see a date.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (11:45.016)
puts the ideal size of a board for the purposes of decision making, ideal size at seven, and again college boards about four times that size on average, and Bain estimates that each member beyond that number results in a 10 % decline in effectiveness. That's gotta be real tough number to calculate, so probably a soft number. And again, to wrap this up, getting 12 people, Brian Rosenberg writes, getting 12 people to spend significant time studying serious challenges.

and then reaching consensus about how to tackle those challenges is a heavy lift. Doing this with 25 or 35, he writes, or 45 people is close to impossible. this is yet another indicator that higher education is not even close, not even close to being able to adjust their business or management models in two.

many cases are of course exceptions I've been in a room with 25 or so board members it is nothing more than a form of quasi organized chaos and in many cases indifference uninformed participation and it continues to be a function of formality and collegiality over substance and action and does this large

Board size contribute to the poor financial performance and concerns about short and long term viability? Absolutely. And I could make a good case that until college boards make themselves smaller and more involved in the colleges finances and future, there is reason to believe that boards will continue to be a major factor in the financial ruin.

in the financial ruin of many more colleges. Private ones will close. Public and some private colleges will merge or otherwise consolidate in that market, as I've said before, with too many college seats and not enough students willing to pay for those seats.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (14:04.077)
How many colleges may close after 2029? This story originated, it was last week, week before last. And I've got a story from Alcino Donadale at University Business on December 4th. And researchers in this study, and again, it was all over the media last week, week before last. Researchers studied everything from an institution's enrollment, endowment, total staff, debt, and other metrics to inform its predictive tool. All right, fair enough.

52 of the 100 institutions that the study identified as the riskiest institutions in higher education closed within three years. Now, I don't see the dates here. However, this is important qualification. I'll come back to this in second, though. However, the study missed the mark on colleges that have already closed that include Birmingham Southern, Iowa Wesleyan, and the University of the Arts in Philadelphia.

52 % out of 52 out of 100, for those that didn't pay attention to math class, 52 % is statistically noteworthy. But it's a risky prediction model for college closures along with all of the human and community elements involved in saying, hey, this college is going to close, or is likely to close. For example, would you send your child to a college for whom a valid statistical projection

a legitimate statistical projection for closure was proven to be correct a little over half the time.

And the challenge, and I've said this many times, and that's the focus of my business model, the challenge is to report on risky colleges while at the same time looking for ways for these colleges, for these at-risk colleges to survive. And as the article correctly notes, these at-risk colleges are a big deal in their communities. And Matt Hendricks, when we do the College Financial Health Show regularly,

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (16:09.236)
mentions his interest in helping these colleges survive using the data he can provide them and his college financial health strategic compass does just that. If you haven't seen our show you want to take a look at that. We're going to be diving more and more into the strategic compass in the weeks and months ahead and nobody in my mind and I could be wrong on this feel free to correct me nobody identifies individual colleges at risk and their unsustainable practices like Matt does.

Nobody identifies those colleges like I do with the college viability app. And that's a big deal. Our focus for students and faculty and community continues to be on the financial health comparisons of individual colleges. The consumers can decide, the faculty can decide, the community can decide, students can decide. We'll provide the data, we'll provide the analysis. Never will we say that any single college will close page.

Three, a reimagined Jewel College. This is just north of Kansas City. This is an internal webpage notice on December 5th. And effectively, it provides a lot of words in the first three or four or five paragraphs, a lot of words to announce that the board has declared a financial exigency at Jewel College. And here's what I noted when I a quick look. Net income.

Operating margins, net tuition revenue are all trending very close to the college financial health advanced compass patterns of recently closed colleges.

Jewel College is tracking at least those parameters I along with recently closed colleges. Draw your own conclusion. And you've heard me say this before. said it earlier in the show.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (18:05.068)
Jewel, why now? These financial challenges are not an overnight development. Time for some entertainment. So let's go to Emporia State University in Kansas, the middle of Kansas. Emporia State University President, Falstek College for Competition and Visions Hostel Takeover.

This is in the Kansas Reflector on December 10th in an article written by Sherman Smith. And this is kind of a fight, fight, fight brewing in the middle of Kansas. Here's the lead from the story. I am going to read it. Emporia State University President Ken Hush, I believe it's how pronounce it. President Ken Hush, in a letter to a local economic development agency, accused Flint Hills Technical College

of competing for students, how un-American, of competing for students, that was my part, of competing for students and warned that lawmakers could force a hostile takeover of the tech college by the university. As always, I'm going to include the link in the show notes. Read the entire story. It is both sad and entertaining in the same breath.

And Emporia State, like Webster University and others, are working hard to show us all how not to run a public or private college and college. does, you got to wonder, does this suggest that if other public or even private colleges face competition, as apparently Emporia State University President Ken Push does not like, do other colleges engage in a hostile?

hostile takeover actions to remove competitors. I would say stay tuned, but I'm not sure I'm gonna stick with this story. It's too off the rails. And then I did a post on this on social media on LinkedIn last week and the headline from a LinkedIn story that I wrote, the headline from a story, new story in Iowa read that Iowa private officials were confident in popularity, sustainability,

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (20:25.302)
of increased financial aid. All right, fair enough. But the article, as I wrote online, I'm going to talk about now, the article is yet another example of colleges spinning incomplete and vague data in hopes of creating nothing more than positive public perception. Now, course, colleges are welcome to do that. Nothing wrong with that. But as we always do here, and you know it,

As we always do here at College Viability, to the data we must go. I'm just going to focus on Simpson College. The other college reference in the story was Drake University. And I'm going to cede that Drake University has a much healthier financial position than Simpson College. And if you want, can watch our mix review that Matt and I had of Drake University on the October 15th, the College Financial Health Show. I'll put the link in the show notes.

The Drake Review starts right at the 16 minute mark. So from 2015 to 2022, Simpson College had a 27 % decrease in FTE enrollment down 400 plus students. The tuition and fee revenue decreased almost $7 million. And while their 2022 endowment was a modest $95 million, their endowment, get this, this is a nuance, this is an inside baseball kind of reflection, their endowment at Simpson College in Iowa

Their endowment only grew 2.6%, 2.6 % from 2016 to 2023. The Simpson College Peer Group, as determined by prospective data science, and the College Financial Health Strategic Compass, the endowment of the peer group for Simpson College increased 45%. That's 45 % in the same time period. So this college, Simpson College, fell significantly

behind many of its competitors in a down-on-growth. To continue graduate student enrollment, a Simpson dropped 64 % down 43 students. Simpson's net tuition revenue mirrored that of recently closed colleges. 34 % from 2016 to 2023.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (22:52.204)
that Hendricks just compiles the data into a database and does the visualization work from there. The college expenses in the face of declining enrollment were up 16%.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (23:06.286)
Expenses up 16 % to Simpson colleges total operating revenues were down almost 14 % So let's look at the spin From the story the first one is the university is up this Simpson College gives me Simpson College is applying University dollars to fill the gap in tuition costs again. This is a tuition a full tuition program is what this call

And the college university is applying dollars to fill the gap in tuition costs. again, I'm going to go inside higher education, inside baseball here. Well, there's no real dollars being used. are for gone dollars. The university is discounting dollars to get students in the door. But it's not real dollars. And I know that's a nuance, but it's an important nuance. There are no real dollars in that kind of statement. And the only university dollars applied are just these non-cash dollars.

They're simply discounts that colleges, like I've said many times, simply discounts that colleges like students and families to believe are real dollars in a form they are, but not in the way they're presented. Gary Stanky, I believe I had that correct, who's the president of the Iowa Association of Independent Colleges and Universities offered the main reason behind these new full-tuition programs.

plays into many of the decisions colleges are making ahead of the enrollment cliff, which is to attract more students and boost enrollment." quote. So I've shared many times that enrollment does not, enrollment alone does not pay the bills. It does not meet payroll. It does not keep the lights on. It is the tuition revenue that these colleges are forgoing. It's the tuition revenue.

that comes from those enrollments and these colleges are saying, you know, we don't need it. Again, that's probably not fair, but these colleges are passing on that revenue and trying to make us think that that's not going to financially impact them. And then again, you know me, I focus on words. Lee Mladzik, I'm going do that again. Lee Mladzik, Lee Mladzik, my apologies, sir. Lee Mladzik, vice president of enrollment at Simpson said the college has seen

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (25:26.35)
Hikes, H-I-K-E-S. College has seen hikes in both revenue and enrollment as a result of the programs, full tuition programs launched just last year. Now I always note vague words like hikes. A good reporter on this story would have asked for that to be quantified. They didn't. And I'll tell you what, I'll cede. They saw a hike, even though it's undocumented and we're taking their word for it.

That does not alter the eight-year trends described above.

I can make an easy argument that the financial trends are not positive and Simpson is trying to PR spin its way out of the real financial health issues. And again, final quote, college officials, and this from the story, college officials agree that they aren't expecting to see any dips in revenue or other negative financial impacts.

from implementing more full-tuition financial aid programs, with Milošić saying the college took a strategic approach to growing both enrollment and revenue streams. Maybe that goes on college drivel for next week. They took a strategic approach. Now, I find this hard to believe because, first of all, it's not really full-tuition. That's how they're describing the program. The college will accept, as I understand it, the college will accept Pell Grants.

as some revenue for these full tuition students and there appears to be some sort of Iowa state government fund to subsidize enrollment.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (27:11.086)
But to do the math, 2022 average net price at Simpson College was $23,000 in change. List price is $45,000, so just counting about 50%, which is normal. grants are about $8,000. So again, get your calculators out of your fingers and toes. $23,000 minus $8,000. Is the state going to provide $15,000 per student to get to just the average net price? And for, you know...

For how many years is the state subsidy going to be available? And what number? Maybe that number's available, I didn't see it. And I understand. This is a Walmart approach to higher education. Get folks in the door with discounted stuff and drive revenue from volume. Assuming enrollment increases, and that is very problematic given the intense competition for students in the Midwest, Iowa included, of course.

At what point does Simpson, if they get all these students in because of this full tuition program, at what point do the college's expenses increase to accommodate that increased enrollment? Faculty, dorms, food, whatever the case may be. This is the money-borrowing error, I've said it many times. Data is always going to be available to support or refute the chronic spin provided by

public and private colleges alike, if their attempt is simply to try and create a positive public perception, and they're more than welcome to give it a shot, if their attempt is to simply try and create a positive public perception, there is appreciable risk, appreciable risk in being caught spinning or ignoring data beyond reason. Let's do a wrap on this episode.

When Gown Leaves Town, an excellent story written by Karen Fisher in The Chronicle on December 13th. When Gown Leaves Town, for communities surrounding small colleges, the losses are more than economic. Now you can guess what the story is about. It's a thorough story. It is an accurate story in my mind. And it at times can be an emotional story.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (29:24.866)
But what Ms. Fisher describes in this article is also necessary.

These closures, be they rural, urban, non-urban areas, are necessary for the economic well-being of this nation so that the colleges that survive have the financial resources to provide a quality college education and not worried about tuition payment, tuition payment to keep the doors open. There are simply too many colleges and not enough students willing to pay for and attend.

those colleges. must change. That balance, that equilibrium must change for higher education to move forward. And industries have left small towns for decades, if not centuries. Higher education is simply another industry that can no longer be supported by these communities. And I know, I know there is trickle-down impact. It is negative trickle-down impact and that it is not pleasant.

There is trauma of all sorts when this happens and it must and will continue for higher education in this country to be the best it can be. Ladies and gentlemen, look at financial college, financial debt all the time, all the time. Colleges are closing and will continue to do so. It is a needed economic adjustment for our nation. I'll be back.

on two days before Christmas. We're back with more higher education news and commentary next Monday on December 23rd. For those who continue to subscribe to this podcast, I'm grateful. I appreciate it. Make sure to drop me a note at gary at college viability.com with suggestions for stories, comments, concerns, and of course criticisms. I welcome those. I encourage those. I always welcome folks who have a different perspective. You can even join me on the podcast if you'd like. And maybe we can even get.

TWICV For Dec 16 2024 (31:32.62)
more of you to join me on this podcast and even on the College Financial Health Show with Matt Hendricks in 2025. At College Viability, I'm Gary Stocker. Good day to all.